• Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
Call us now: 01243 836 840   [email protected]
Pure Employment Law
  • Who We Are
    • Nicola Brown
    • Peter Stevens
    • Elena Elsam
    • David Jones
    • Linda Nye
    • Brenda Cherry
  • For Employers
    • Advice on HR and People issues
    • Investigations, Hearings and Appeals
    • Restructuring and Redundancy
    • Defending Employment Tribunal Claims
    • Dismissal of Senior Executives
    • Contracts, Handbooks and Policies
    • Employment Law Training
  • For Employees
    • Settlement Agreements
    • Workplace Issues including Disciplinary and Grievance
    • Bringing an Employment Tribunal Claim
  • Employment Law Events
  • Legal Updates
  • Testimonials
  • Vacancies
  • Contact us
  • Search
  • Menu Menu

Penalty? Dealing with repayment provisions

28th November 2013/in News /by Nicola Brown

Employers often put provisions in contracts of employment requiring an employee to repay sums which the employer has spent on behalf of that employee. A common example is a requirement to repay the costs of a training course if the employee leaves their employment. Usually, these provisions operate for a fixed period, for example 12 months from completion of the course, and frequently the level of repayment is on a sliding scale, for example 100% repayment if they leave within 3 months of the course finishing, 75% if they leave between 3 and 6 months of the course finishing and so on.

These types of provisions are perfectly lawful and enforceable, provided that they are reasonable and do not operate in restraint of trade. For example, if an employer required repayment of a training course fee if the employee left their employment within 5 years of the end of the course, then that would almost certainly be unenforceable as it arguably would prevent, or at least penalise, the employee for leaving their employment.

Repayment clauses are frequently linked to a provision in the contract allowing the employer to deduct any sums from any wages owed to the employee. This is done so as to avoid the limitations on an employer’s ability to deduct sums from an employee’s wages contained in the Employment Rights Act 1996.

In the recent case of Cleeve Link Limited v Bryla [2013] the Employment Appeal Tribunal had to consider whether a repayment provision amounted to a penalty clause. Penalty clauses are provisions in a contract which provide for a sanction to be imposed on a party to the contract where that sanction is not a genuine pre estimate of the loss suffered by the other party. For example, if an employer provided that an employee would have to pay a sum of £5,000 if they resigned from their employment without giving the required notice, that provision would almost certainly be a penalty clause, and as such be unenforceable. In Cleeve Link, the employer had paid fees to a recruitment agency in Poland, and also paid the employee’s air fare.  The contract provided that these costs could be recovered in full if the employee’s employment ended within 6 months of her starting the employment, with the amount of the repayment reducing over a period of time after that. Mrs Bryla was dismissed after 12 weeks. At the time she was owed just over £1,200. The employer deducted the entire sum with the result that she was paid nothing. Mrs Bryla brought a claim in the Employment Tribunal claiming an unauthorised deduction of wages.

In the Employment Tribunal, the Employment Judge held that the clause was not a genuine pre estimate of loss, but was a penalty clause. As such, he held that the employer had no right to deduct the sum from Mrs Bryla’s pay. The employer appealed to the Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT).

The EAT overturned the decision. They said that the sums deducted were a genuine pre estimate of loss at the time the contract was entered into. The employer had also argued that the contractual provision relating to penalty clauses had no place in the context of a statutory employment claim for an unauthorised deduction of wages, i.e. if the right to deduct was in the contract, then the Employment Tribunal should not look any further. The EAT disagreed. They held that you initially had to determine whether the sum was properly due, and only if it was did the statutory right to deduct wages come into play.

The EAT also provided guidance as to when a repayment clause may be enforceable. They said that the starting point is to look at the contract when it was entered into. The Employment Tribunal must then decide, objectively, whether the purpose of the clause was to deter the employee from leaving or whether it represented a genuine pre estimate of loss. The answer to this question may involve a comparison between the amount stated in the clause and a realistic figure the employer might recover. If the difference is “extravagant” or “unconscionable”, then the clause is likely to be unenforceable.

This case illustrates the complexity behind what appears to be a straightforward repayment provision. Employers should ensure that any repayment provisions are reasonable and likely to be enforceable, and if they have any doubt as to the drafting of these clauses, should take specialist advice.

If you would like to talk through a situation you are dealing with, or if you need advice on any aspect of employment law, please contact any member of the Pure Employment Law team (01243 836840 or [email protected]).

Please note that this update is not intended to be exhaustive or be a substitute for legal advice. The application of the law in this area will often depend upon the specific facts and you are advised to seek specific advice on any given scenario.
Share this article
  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
  • Share on WhatsApp
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share on Reddit
  • Share by Mail
https://www.pureemploymentlaw.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Pure-Employment-Law-logo.jpg 0 0 Nicola Brown https://www.pureemploymentlaw.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Pure-Employment-Law-logo.jpg Nicola Brown2013-11-28 11:10:312014-12-03 15:20:22Penalty? Dealing with repayment provisions

Join our mailing list

* = required field
Mailing Lists


Recent Legal Updates

  • FAQs about COT3s 18th December 2020
  • Can an employer withdraw a notice of redundancy? 18th December 2020
  • Will employers be able to insist that staff have the Covid-19 vaccination? 18th December 2020
  • Furlough over Christmas? 18th December 2020
  • Update – Furlough scheme extended 18th December 2020
Link to: Contact Us

Any questions? Why not get in touch!

Our advice is always given in plain English without any waffle, and we focus on providing practical solutions to our clients’ problems.

Contact us

LEGAL INFORMATION

Pure Employment Law | 1 Little London, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 1PH
[email protected] | Tel: 01243 836840

Pure Employment Law is the trading name of Pure Employment Law Limited, registered in England and Wales with company number 07134294 and whose registered office is 1 Little London, Chichester, West Sussex, PO19 1PH. Pure Employment Law Limited is authorised and regulated by the Solicitors Regulation Authority with registration number 533794. A list of the company’s directors is available for inspection at the registered office

DISCLAIMER

The information contained in this website is for general information purposes only. The information is provided by Pure Employment Law and while we endeavour to keep the information up to date and correct, we make no representations or warranties of any kind, express or implied, about the completeness, accuracy, reliability, suitability or availability with respect to the website or the information, products, services, or related graphics contained on the website for any purpose. Any reliance you place on such information is therefore strictly at your own risk.

Privacy Policy | Cookies Policy | Terms & Conditions | How to make a complaint | Sitemap

© Pure Employment Law 2021

Scroll to top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies as defined in our cookie policy.

Accept Cookie Policy

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refuseing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.

We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.

We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.

Google Analytics Cookies

These cookies collect information that is used either in aggregate form to help us understand how our website is being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are, or to help us customize our website and application for you in order to enhance your experience.

If you do not want that we track your visit to our site you can disable tracking in your browser here:

Other external services

We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Google Map Settings:

Google reCaptcha Settings:

Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

Other cookies

The following cookies are also needed - You can choose if you want to allow them:

Privacy Policy

You can read about our cookies and privacy settings in detail on our Privacy Policy Page.

Privacy Policy
Accept settingsHide notification only